North Sound Valuation of Seattle

    CMA or appraisal: which answers your question?

    If you are deciding between a broker's CMA and an appraisal, begin with what you need the value for. The right choice depends on who will use it and what they require.

    A blue-gray cottage with a covered porch and evergreen trees.

    Appraisal guide | Originally published 2025-06-18

    Choose by the question you need answered and who will use the result. For a possible listing, ask your broker for a comparative market analysis, or CMA. For an estate, divorce, mortgage, or tax matter, confirm the recipient's requirements before ordering either document.

    Start with the decision

    For a listing discussion, ask how recent sales, competing listings, and your home's condition support the proposed asking price. Ask which evidence is strongest and what would change the recommendation. If you need an appraisal, explain the purpose and intended users. Washington adopts professional appraisal standards through its appraisal standards rule.

    Do not assume a broker's pricing document and an appraisal are interchangeable. Washington law distinguishes a broker's price opinion from an appraisal and restricts its use as an appraisal in a federally related transaction. See RCW 18.140.020.

    Your questionWho should confirm the instructions?
    What asking price should we discuss?Your listing broker. Ask what the CMA covers.
    What value does an estate need?The personal representative and estate attorney or tax adviser.
    What valuation supports a divorce matter?Your attorney, including any court or agreed instructions.
    What will a mortgage lender accept?The lender, including its ordering process.
    What documentation supports a tax position?Your tax adviser, including the applicable valuation date.

    Check the date and condition

    Ask for the date the value applies to as well as the date the report is written. For an earlier valuation date, provide photographs, repair records, and other information about the property's condition then. Ask how the analysis handles completed renovations, unfinished work, or assumed repairs. Compare these instructions before comparing conclusions.

    One house, two different questions

    Consider a hypothetical Seattle family preparing an inherited house for sale. Their broker is discussing an asking price for the home in today's market. Separately, the personal representative may need its value on the date of passing, before later renovations. Washington law permits a personal representative to hire qualified, disinterested help with an estate valuation when the value is reasonably in doubt. See RCW 11.44.070. Today's listing discussion and the earlier valuation address different questions about the same house.

    Before ordering, write down the recipient, purpose, valuation date, condition instructions, and deadline. Have the recipient confirm what it needs, then give those instructions to the professional preparing the work.

    For the property information to gather, see residential appraisals or probate appraisal preparation.

    North Sound Valuation of Seattle

    Talk through the property and the purpose.

    Tell us the property address, why you need the appraisal and any deadline. We can discuss the scope before you decide how to proceed.

    206-350-7003Send an appraisal inquiry

    North Sound Valuation of Seattle

    Tell us about the home.
    We’ll talk through the appraisal.

    Call us206-350-7003